Catherine or Katherine?

[lordbyron227]

I prefer Katherine....although Catherine is cute.

I got Katherine's True End, although I'm not sure if this was because I answered "honestly" or because I was aiming for the Katherine Ending (and thus "gamed the answers) because that's what I felt was right as a result a combination of Confucian upbringing and some personal family matters when I was young makes "cheating", and thus being with Catherine a big no-no (lol), despite all of her attractiveness (and voice......Rise ftw).

Minor Spoilers for the 1st Paragraph. That last bit has a slightly bigger spoiler.

Some other thoughts - I do think that one question asked by that sheep was a nice touch, the one where he asked whether or not one was answering honestly, or just the something that sounds right. Which to be honest, I find a little blurry b/c of my personal outlook. I guess I'm one of the players who is a lying liar that lies to myself eh (to quote this podcast http://www.popmatters.com/pm/post/14...-and-catherine). Although it was interesting that by admitting you may be less than honest in your answers, the meter goes towards the lawful end.

I was playing heavily order on my 1st Playthru and I was devastated when Katherine dumps Vincent the 1st time...although,. it was expected. I did want to get her back also.



End Spoilers

[trismegistus]

Ehh...both girls are cute...I like McBride's look better, but personality-wise she was pretty irritating...not that bubbly Catherine much better. Yeah, I'm gonna have to say Erica for this one, can't go wrong with redheads.

[crimson knight]

i chose katherine, she just seems better than catherine. or is catherine better than katherine? i am so confused. who is who again?

[EmilIrving]

Originally Posted by trismegistus

Ehh...both girls are cute...I like McBride's look better, but personality-wise she was pretty irritating...not that bubbly Catherine much better. Yeah, I'm gonna have to say Erica for this one, can't go wrong with redheads.

Catherine or Katherine... I CHOOSE NEITHER! Instead I go with Trisha.

[crimson knight]

you guysc wonder if atlus is secretly saying something about the ps3 with the different cover?

[Jack of Plaid]

Katherine.

[chimu]

i'll choose catherine.

the only problem with her is that she can seem too psychotic at times. atleast untill you find out her true self which is too much of a spoiler to discuss.

[Sikboy1029]

They're both crazy so it would be a tough choice.

[izanagi_the_creator]

I chose Catherine.

Well, she is cute and she protects Vincent. She is a succubus, daughter of a powerful demon lord. Aside from that, she is chaos.. That's kind of cool..

Only problem with her is that she might disappear all of a sudden and Vincent will have no idea where to find her again. This makes me want to choose Katherine instead but I already made my choice. Maybe, its a poor choice.. Oh well, too bad..

[Boyzby]

I've always preferred Katherine. She has many traits that I like in a person which I could not list and describe in an interesting way.

[EightBitRed]

The real question you should ask yourself is...

Would you pick a slut or someone that's loyal to you?

[Killionaire]

I picked Katherine. When I first played the game I knew it was the way to go, haha. Even though she seemed uber serious all the time, her and Vincent seemed perfect in a way.

[AXidenT]

In real life, Katherine because it seems the more real choice, but in the game Catherine because it's fun.

[Tylerthedragon]

Katherine , because she takes things seriously , she doesent think "okay , we can talk later , but S*X NAO PLOX" shes much more mature for a 32 year old woman , and that seems better than having yourself be used for a S*x slave

[Kahalachan]

IRL I'm with a more Catherine type girl. One of my exes was a Katherine type of girl and she just got too annoying. After her I went for more Catherine type girls.

I'm halfway through the game (which is why I won't vote on the poll yet) and my meter is in the middle so I'm not quite sure what I'll choose game wise but I'm answering questions honestly and reacting how I think I would so we'll see.

Edit:

Lookswise I prefer Katherine.

[DingoEnderZOE2]

Well personally I would chose a girl like Catherine, I prefer my girls to be bubbly,exciting and fun.

I'm not compatible at all with people who are too serious or too by the book which is why choosing a girl like Katherine would be tough for me.

[Lord_Shiva]

I found Catherine annoyingly manipulative - and I prefer Katherine's looks and personality.

So Katherine for sure.

But I am a complete sucker for bad girls, despite knowing if you want a happy life, you shouldn't pick the femme fatale.

[Agent Chieftain]

Katherine for me. I didn't find Catherine all that attractive for some reason. Though I guess that's because we saw what she looked like as Vince's ideal woman and not necessarily our ideal woman.

[Taziam]

Catherine.

[soapstone]

Originally Posted by Crabman

I love my homewreckers <3

lol, when i started and even at the end, before the actuality of what was going on was revealed, i did not trust Katherine (there was ants every time you see her) so i felt sure she was the witch and would be bad news for vince, catherine did act questionable, but i trusted her more than i did katherine. my friend on the other hand, hates catherine but loves katherine, lol.

[killamonjaro]

whats with all these Kathrine choices?
Cathrine is way hotter and she wants the D, i say give it to her XD

[namelessregret]

Katherine looks better to me.

[globalcooling]

Catherine.

[Lehst]

Katherine.
but... that's because I could really relate to her. She seemed a lot like me (but with a better career). Hell I even look like her with the hair/glasses/fashion.

Catherine is super cute though, but I loved the game cover with Katherine way more.


haha, good thing this discussion is in text... its so funny hearing Catherine, Katherine, Catherine out loud.

[Anansi]

C over K, as much as I like women with glasses Catherine is very fun also a demon, so I know she can tell me some pretty interesting things she's done with her immortal life.